Have you ever wondered which ring goes on your finger first—your engagement ring or the wedding band? If you have, you're not ...

The couple showed off their matching wedding bands (and black manicures!) when they announced their surprise nuptials on Instagram Kaitlyn is a former Assistant Style & Beauty Editor at PEOPLE.

She was over the moon about it," he writes. Getty Later, he purchased the matching wedding band, noting that it was "also very expensive for me," adding that "again she was super happy ...